Some short comments on argumentation by a former French Waldorf teacher
Some years ago, someone who worked as a Steiner Waldorf teacher in France had a mental collapse in connection with having to leave his work at the school. Since then, as a revenge he has published a number of articles that criticize and with little justification defame his former school and Steiner Waldorf education.
One of the things he claims is that the schools engage in indoctrination of the pupils with anthroposophy.
One of his arguments for this is that they are taught that the human being and other organisms biologically exhibit a threefold structure. According to him, this is an example of anthroposophical indoctrination.
The reason for this is not any specific anthroposophical thesis, but that the germ out of which organisms develop has a basic threefold structure, with an endoderm, a mesoderm and an ectoderm, and that this is reflected in the way the fully developed organism is structured and functions.
Before developing into an embryo, the human egg is polarized into a vegetative pole and an "animal" pole. The polarization of the egg constitutes the basis for the later polarization of the human embryo into the development of nutritional organs out of the vegetative pole of the egg, and the organs of the nervous system out of the "animal" pole of the egg.He also exemplifies his thesis of anthroposophical indoctrination with the way animal physiology is introduced in grade four with the cow, the lion and the eagle as examples.
According to the teacher, this constitutes anthroposophical indocrination, as Rudolf Steiner as the founder of both anthroposophy and Steiner Waldorf education also commented on the bull/cow, the lion, and the eagle/scorpio as representatives of three of the four evangelists in the Apocalypse of St John and in Christian iconography.
That is not the reason for starting to teach animal physiology out of the cow, the lion, and the eagle as examples, but because they on a macroscopic level in a one sided way have developed what is reflected already in the embryo, with its development of the nutritional organs out of the endoderm (cow), the heart and circulation out of the mesoderm (lion), and the sense/nervous system out of the ectoderm (eagle). It builds a transdisciplinary understanding of the relation between otherwise to most unrelated subjects.He also describes other examples of what he considers to be anthroposophical indoctrination.
Steiner Waldorf education moves from a stress on a generic reverent attitude to the world in general in early childhood, cultivating the experience that the world is a good place to live in in Kindergarten, out of a family type of environment for the children.Children also need to get acquainted with and understand personally the basis for different religious world views held by the majority of the peoples in the world out of their own experiences.
If they don't get acquainted with also different religious perspectives and rituals when they grow up, and that are held by the great majority of the world population as also with the arguments for the opposite, rationalist and atheist view, how can they develop their own worldview, based on their own thinking and considerations, and understand others who have other world views than they have?Steiner waldorf education does not see it as its goal to choose for the pupils how to see and understand the world, but to build an understanding of the pupils for all possible worldviews in a systematic way from childhood to adulthood, out of the inner situation of the pupils at the different stages of their path from childhood to adulthood, to make it possible for them to build their own life view as adults out of their own reflections and considerations.
That is Steiner Waldorf education.
According to the French former Steiner Waldorf teacher, this way of building the freedom for the pupils to cultivate their own world view and choose their individual paths in life as adults makes it into a "cult", a specific concept in French legislation, where it refers to "sectarian groups that undermine human rights and fundamental freedoms of the individual", a serious and untrue allegation about Steiner Waldorf schools.
The French Federation of Steiner Waldorf schools does not agree with him and therefore sued him for libel.
The case was tried in court on 7 April 2013.